Wednesday, June 3, 2020

THE APPLICATION OF GOOD BEHAVIOUR BOND UNDER CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE FOR OFFENCES CHARGED UNDER CUSTOMS ACT 1967(ACT 235)

Introduction: There are cases where the accused feels appropriate to apply to the Court for a discharge conditionally or unconditionally under Criminal Procedure Code (CPC). A conditional discharge is commonly known as good behaviour bond (binding over).

How to apply: The application for good behaviour bond is made orally at the mitigation and sentencing stage pursuant to Section 173A or 294 of CPC.

The distinction between Section 173A and 294 of CPC:-

Section 173A
-
A binding over without a conviction being recorded when the charge is proved against the accused.
Section 294
-
A binding over upon conviction being recorded first.

The pre-requisite for the application of Section 294 of CPC:-

1.
The accused must be a first offender;
2.
The accused has been convicted for the offence;
3.
The accused good character;
4.
The accused past history;
5.
The accused age;
6.
The accused health; or
7.
The accused mental condition; or
8.
The trivial (insignificant) nature of the offence; or
9.
Any extenuating (mitigating) circumstances under which the offence was committed.

The application of Section 294 of CPC for offences charged under Customs Act 1967:-

The amendment of Criminal Procedure Code vide Criminal Procedure Code (Amendment) Act 2016 (Act A1521) which came into force on 1st March 2017 added Section 294(6)(a) to the effect that Section 294 of CPC shall not apply if the offender is charged with a “serious offence”.

This significant amendment removes the discretion of the Magistrate/Judge to grant good behaviour bond if the offence charged fall under the definition of a “serious offence”.

The Customs Act 1967 had not defined any of its Customs offences as “serious offence”. Nevertheless, the Subsection 3(1) of Anti-Money Laundering, Anti-Terrorism Financing and Proceeds of Unlawful Activities Act 2001 has defined “serious offence” as any of the offences specified in the Second Schedule [Section 3, definition of “serious offence”] which includes offences under Section 133, 135 and 137 of Customs Act 1967.

Although, the Customs Act 1967 had not define any of its offences as “serious offence” but the offences committed under Customs Act 1967 is serious in nature. Upon realizing the seriousness of the offence and taking into account of the public interest element, the Parliament had amended the Customs Act 1967 in which the amendments came into force on 2nd January 2019 to impose more stringent penalties for offences under Section 133, 134, 135, 136, 137 and 138 of Customs Act 1967.

In addition to that, the amendments had introduced a new Section 119A of Customs Act 1967 to give power to the Court to order the accused to pay the customs duty and penalty payable under this Act when the accused is found guilty of an offence under the same Act.

Thus, the said amendments had proved the utmost intention of Legislature to codify offences under Customs Act 1967 as “serious offence” to enable the authorities in curbing tax revenue offences (economical offences) driven through underground trade.

In short, the failure to define “serious offence” in the Customs Act 1967 is merely a lacuna (gap).

Thursday, May 28, 2020

THE LAW ON SUMMARY JUDGMENT

The law: A Summary Judgment (also judgment as a matter of law) is a Judgment entered by a Court for one party and against another party summarily without a full trial. Such a Judgment may be issued on the merits of an entire case, or on discrete issues in that case. The Summary Judgment is provided under Order 14 Rules of Court 2012.

Objective: To avoid the waste of unnecessary costs and time of the parties and Court for legal suits with facts and issues which are clear and straight forward.   

Who can file the application for Summary Judgment: Plaintiff in an action commenced by way of Writ Summons may apply to court for a Summary Judgment except for those actions stated under Order 14 rule 1(2)(a) and (b) Rules of Court 2012 which are:-

Order 14 rule 1(2)(a):-
Claims by the Plaintiff for libel, slander, malicious prosecution, false imprisonment, seduction or breach of promise of marriage.

Order 14 rule 1(2)(b):-
Claims by the Plaintiff based on an allegation of fraud.

The Grounds for Summary Judgment: That the Defendant has no defence to the Plaintiff’s claim or part of claim. In cases where the defence filed is a sham one and where there is really no triable issues that would require a full hearing.

Alternatively, the Plaintiff may apply to have the defence to be struck off on the grounds that it discloses no reasonable defence or that it is “scandalous, frivolous or vexatious” or that it may “prejudice, embarrass or delay the fair trial of the action” or that it is otherwise an abuse of the process of the court”.

When to file the Summary Judgment: The Summary Judgment must be filed when the defendant has enter the appearance.

The Notice of Application (Form 57) for Summary Judgment is to be supported by an Affidavit (Form 13) setting out clearly the claim, and it must be specifically stated that the defendant has no defence to the action, or that the defence filed is a sham case.

Case Laws on Principles Governing the Summary Judgment:
1.National Company For Foreign Trade v. Kayu Raya Sdn Bhd [1984] 1 CLJ (Rep) 283;
2.Gold Ores Reduction Co. v. Pain [1892] 2 QB 14;
3.Chen Heng Ping@ Tian Seow Hock & 5 Ors v. Intradagang Merchant Bankers (M) Berhad [1995] 3 CLJ 690;
4.Bank Negara Malaysia v Mohd Ismail & Ors [1992] 1 MLJ 400;
5.South East Asia Insurance Bhd v. Kerajaan Malaysia [1998] 1 CLJ 1045

Wednesday, May 27, 2020

FLOWCHART: CIVIL PROCEEDINGS FOR ACTION COMMENCED BY WAY OF WRIT UNDER RULES OF COURT 2012

Issue Letter of Demand

↓

Filing of Writ Summons

Prepare and complete documents for filing to Court:-

(a) Form 2 – Writ (High Court); or

(b) Form 2A – Writ (Subordinate Court); and

(c) Form 11 – Memorandum of Appearance (Memorandum of Appearance in duplicate to be appended to Writ); and

(d) Statement of Claims

↓

Service of Writ by way of Personal Service or Prepaid A.R. Registered Post

↓

Service of Writ Successful

Service of Writ Unsuccessful

↓

↓

Make another attempt of Service and if failed

↓

Prepare Affidavit of Non-Service of the Writ

↓

File Notice of Application (Form 57) supported by an Affidavit (Form 134) for a Court Order to serve the Writ by way of Substituted Service

↓

Order for Substituted Service made by the Court (Form 133) upon Hearing the Application

↓

Substituted Service of the Writ as per Court Order (example: publication in the local newspaper)

↓

Affidavit of Service for Writ (Form 135)

↓

Defendant to file:-

(a) Memorandum of Appearance

(b) Statement of Defence and Counterclaim (if any)

↓

↓

Defendant not file the Memorandum of Appearance

Defendant files the Memorandum of Appearance

↓

↓

On the 1st Return Date the Defendant may:-

(a) not appear; or
(b) appear and admit the claim; or
(c) appear and dispute the claim (Statement of Defence)

On the 1st Return Date the Defendant will:-

(a) appear and admit the claim; or

 (b) appear and dispute the claim (Statement of Defence)

↓

↓

↓

(a) If the Defendant not appear

(b) If the Defendant appear and dispute the claim

(c) If the Defendant appear and admit the claim

↓

↓

↓

Judgment In Default of Appearance

Defendant to file Statement of Defence

Consent Judgment

↓

Plaintiff to decide whether:-

↓

To apply Summary Judgment

To wait for a Full Trial Date

↓

↓

 

 

Plaintiff to file Notice of Application (Form 57) supported by an Affidavit (Form 13)

↓

Hearing of Application for Summary Judgment

↓

Court’s Decision

↓

↓

No Triable Issue

Triable Issue

↓

↓

Order for Summary Judgment

Full Trial Date

 

↓

Court’s Decision after Full Trial

↓

Judgment after Full Trial

Monday, May 4, 2020

CARA MEMOHON PENDAFTARAN PERSATUAN PENGANUT HINDU DENGAN JABATAN PENDAFTARAN PERTUBUHAN MALAYSIA (JPPM)

1.-Satu mesyuarat penubuhan yang dihadiri minimum 7 orang hendaklah diadakan dan nama mereka yang hadir hendaklah dicatatkan dalam minit mesyuarat penubuhan.

2.-Mesyuarat penubuhan hendaklah membuat ketetapan seperti berikut:

(a)-bersetuju menubuhkan pertubuhan;

(b)-meluluskan nama pertubuhan yang akan didaftarkan;
(nama pertubuhan hendaklah selaras dengan tujuan dan keahlian pertubuhan)

(c)-menetapkan alamat tempat urusan bagi pertubuhan yang akan didaftarkan;

(d)-melantik AJK Penaja Pertubuhan minimum 7 orang untuk menguruskan pendaftaran pertubuhan;

(e)- sediakan senarai AJK Penaja; dan

(f)-meluluskan undang-undang (perlembagaan) bagi pertubuhan yang hendak didaftarkan termasuk bendera, lambang dan lencana dengan keterangan (jika berkenaan);

3.-Senarai AJK Penaja hendaklah mengandungi butiran setiap AJK Penaja mengikut format yang ditetapkan oleh JPPM iaitu seperti berikut:

(a)-Jawatan dalam pertubuhan;

(b)-Nama penuh seperti dalam myKad;

(c)-Jantina;

(d)-Nombor kad pengenalan baru dan lama;

(e)-Warganegara;

(f)-Tarikh lahir dan Tempat lahir (daerah);

(g)-Pekerjaan;

(h)-Nama dan Alamat majikan;

(i)-Alamat kediaman semasa;

(j)-Nombor telefon (Rumah/Bimbit/Pejabat); dan

(d)-Emel;

4.-Setiap Ahli Jawatankuasa bagi Pertubuhan hendaklah dipastikan tidak hilang kelayakan memegang jawatan di bawah Seksyen 9A dan Seksyen 49 Akta Pertubuhan 1966.

5.-Minit Mesyuarat Penubuhan yang mencatatkan perjalanan mesyuarat penubuhan pertubuhan dan keputusan terhadap ketetapan-ketetapan yang dibuat hendaklah disediakan.

6.-Setiausaha Penaja hendaklah membuat pendaftaran pertubuhan secara online melalui sistem eROSES di www.eroses.gov.my.

7.-Bayaran Pendaftaran Pertubuhan sebanyak RM30.00 akan dikenakan bagi setiap permohonan yang dibuat.

8.-Pembayaran Fi boleh dibayar melalui kaunter JPPM atau secara online.

9.-Pertubuhan yang dibatalkan pendaftarannya selepas memperoleh kelulusan penubuhan mempunyai hak di sisi undang-undang seperti berikut:-

(a)-Membuat rayuan kepada Menteri Dalam Negeri dalam tempoh 30 hari dari tarikh perintah pembatalan; atau

(b)-Memfailkan Permohonan Semakan Kehakiman di Mahkamah Tinggi dalam tempoh 3 bulan dari tarikh perintah pembatalan.

Friday, April 24, 2020

EMPLOYERS, EMPLOYEES & WAGES DURING MOVEMENT CONTROL ORDER (MCO)

1.-Payment of employee’s wages are governed by the Employment Act 1955 or employment contract which comes under purview of Ministry of Human Resources.

2.-Section 2(1) of the Employment Act 1955 define wages as “basic wages and all other payments in cash payable to an employee for work done”.

3.-In a contract, one consideration (work done) is exchanged for another consideration (wages) based on employment contract.

4.-The question is whether the employees are entitled for the wages for unattended work due to the MCO?

5.-The MCO was issued pursuant to the Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases Act 1988 and the Police Act 1967.

6.-The Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases Act 1988 comes under purview of Ministry of Health.

7.-The Police Act 1967 comes under purview of Ministry of Home Affairs.

8.-The Employment Act 1955, Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases Act 1988, Police Act 1967 and MCO is silent on the employee’s wages in the event of business shut down due to the MCO.

9.-Whether it is lawful for employers to exercise deduction of wages or non-payment of wages of the employees in the event of business shut down due to the MCO?

10.-The High Court case of Viking Askim Sdn Bhd v National Union of Employees in Companies Manufacturing Rubber Products (1991) 3 CLJ (Rep) 195 held as follows:

“…[6] if an employee is ready to perform his services during the period covered by his contract of employment, which provides for payment of wages at certain times, he is entitled to the wages, although the employer has no work for him…”

11.-In applying the above case into the current situation where businesses are shut down due to the MCO, none of the employees are considered to be ready to perform their duty and services.

12.-So, it is plain and obvious that the employees are not entitled to wages for unattended work due to the MCO.

13.-The announcement of MCO is a situation that is beyond the control (force majeure) of both the employers and employees which could cause the suspension of employment contractual obligations.

14.-The doctrine of frustration is applies where the performance of the employment contract becomes impossible by both employers and employees.

15.-It is therefore, any guides issued by the Ministry of Human Resources that related to employment and wages during MCO must not misconceived in law and fact. It is trite law that one cannot widen or narrow the scope of legislation through the issuance of guidelines.

Tuesday, April 21, 2020

INCREASED PENALTIES FOR SMUGGLING OFFENCES UNDER CUSTOMS ACT 1967

Overview:
The recent amended to the Customs Act 1967 which was gazetted on 28th December 2018 and effective on 2nd January 2019 brought changes to the penalties related to smuggling offences under the Customs Act 1967.

Content:
The amendment had introduced heavier penalties for smuggling offences relating to cigarettes containing tobacco and intoxicating liquor besides increased the penalties for prevailing smuggling offences under Section 135 of the Customs Act 1967. The comparison of penalties before and after amendment are as summarized in the schedule below:-

Maximum penalty
before amendment
Maximum penalty
after amendment
penalty relating to smuggling offences, evasion of duty, fraud, etc
cases involving dutiable goods including cigarettes containing tobacco and intoxicating liquor
cases involving dutiable goods other than cigarettes containing tobacco and intoxicating liquor
1st offence
Fine not more than 20 times of the customs duty or imprisonment up to 3 years or to both


2nd & subsequent offence
Fine not more than 40 times of the customs duty or imprisonment up to 5 years or to both
1st offence
Fine not more than 20 times of the customs duty or RM 500,000 (whichever greater) or imprisonment up to 5 years or to both

2nd & subsequent offence
Fine not more than 40 times of the customs duty or RM 1,000,000 (whichever greater) or imprisonment up to 7 years or to both
cases involving prohibited goods including cigarettes containing tobacco and intoxicating liquor
cases involving prohibited goods other than cigarettes containing tobacco and intoxicating liquor
1st offence
Fine not more than 20 times the value of the goods or imprisonment up to 3 years or to both


2nd & subsequent offence
Fine not more than 40 times the value of the goods or imprisonment up to 5 years or to both
1st offence
Fine not more than 20 times the value of the goods or RM 500,000 (whichever greater) or imprisonment up to 5 years or to both

2nd & subsequent offence
Fine not more than 40 times the value of the goods or RM 1,000,000 (whichever greater) or imprisonment up to 7 years or to both
-Nil-
cases involving dutiable cigarettes containing tobacco or intoxicating liquor




-
1st offence
Fine not more than 20 times of the customs duty or RM 500,000 (whichever greater) or imprisonment up to 5 years or to both

2nd & subsequent offence
Fine not more than 40 times of the customs duty or RM 1,000,000 (whichever greater) or imprisonment up to 5 years or to both
-Nil-
cases involving cigarettes containing tobacco or intoxicating liquor which are prohibited goods




-



1st offence
Fine not more than 20 times the value of the goods or RM 500,000 (whichever greater) or imprisonment up to 5 years or to both

2nd & subsequent offence
Fine not more than 40 times the value of the goods or RM 1,000,000 (whichever greater) or imprisonment up to 5 years or to both

Conclusion:
The significant increase in the quantum of penalties for economical offenders in the recent amendments to the Customs Act 1967 is to ensure strict enforcement by Customs authority in curbing smuggling offences irrespective of quantity and value. Thus, in simplicity the amendment disclose the ultimate intention of Legislature to enable the Customs authority to arrest anyone in the streets found carrying or in possession of any class of dutiable/uncustomed/prohibited goods on import or export and demand for the production of proof on the payment of duties; failing which to charge the person arrested in the court of law.